Legal
Officials, Litigants See Savings in Time and Money
From the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel Feb. 2, 1997
© 2000 Journal Sentinel Inc., Reprinted
with permission
by: Betsy Thatcher of the Journal Sentinel staff
"I'll see you in court!" is not
likely to be replaced by "I'll see you in mediation!" but the new spin
on that familiar phrase is not far from the truth.
A year ago, Waukesha County Circuit
Judge Patrick L. Snyder said he was ordering mediation in about 15%
of the civil cases that came before him. Now that number is closer
to 60%.
"A few years ago, you wouldn't
even recommend mediation to anybody. Nobody did it. It was just new," Snyder
said.
These days Snyder offers it in
nearly every case he handles in civil court.
About 1990, some judges began
encouraging mediation but it wasn't until July 1994 that the Legislature
gave Wisconsin judges the authority to order mediation, Snyder said.
"Even then, I wasn't picking up
on it in every case," he said. "Now I routinely ask in every case."
Mediation is just one form of
what is known as "alternative dispute resolution," a tool for the state's
judges that contains a set of options for settling legal disputes before
they get on the time-consuming and costly track toward trial.
"That's a hot topic these days," said
Milwaukee criminal defense attorney Stephen M. Glynn.
Although mediation is not an option
for criminal judges, a number of mediators are criminal and civil trial
lawyers or retired trial judges, Glynn said. Often mediation involves "testing" a
trial strategy on a mediator who can give an opinion to the parties
on whether their strategies would work in a real trial, Glynn said.
In addition to trial lawyers and
retired judges, experts in various fields who do not have law degrees
act as court-appointed mediators.
Last year, a dispute between the
Village of Lannon and its neighbor, the Town of Lisbon, over land access
landed in Snyder's court.
The dispute was related to Lannon's
construction of a sanitary sewer system. Litigation would have been
time-consuming and costly, because the multimillion-dollar project
was being held up. So Snyder asked for mediation.
Snyder called in Kurt Schrang,
an Oconomowoc construction consultant who has been a contractor for
35 years and who has done mediation and arbitration work in the construction
industry for 18 years.
"He saved those two municipalities
$100,000 apiece," Snyder said of Schrang, who helped the communities
devise a solution.
It's important to keep in mind
that Schrang and other mediators like him are not practicing law when
they are appointed by a judge, Schrang said.
"The court gives you a certain
set of instructions as to how far you can go and that everybody has
to agree to," Schrang said.
Alternative dispute resolution
is sweeping through Wisconsin courts and in certain industries with
such gusto that, in 1993, Marquette University established the Center
for Dispute Resolution Education. In fall of 1995, it inaugurated a
five-course graduate program in dispute resolution that was the first
in the state.
About one-third of its students
are lawyers. Another third are psychologists and social workers who
mainly do divorce mediation, said Eva M. Soeka, Associate Professor
of Law and the Center's Director.
"There's been a great deal of
judicial education (on mediation) in the state since the 1994 law took
effect," Soeka said.
"My sense is that it's being accepted and even welcomed
by judges," Soeka said.

|